Skip to content
FriendsPantry

American · Sandwiches

Beef on weck (Buffalo roast beef sandwich)

Non-vegetarian

Thin slices of rare roast beef piled into a kummelweck roll crusted with coarse salt and caraway, the top dipped in beef jus, finished with sharp freshly grated horseradish. After chicken wings, it is Buffalo's best-loved food.

Beef on weck (Buffalo roast beef sandwich) is an American sandwich from United States, ready in about 1 hour 55 minutes and made with beef sirloin steak, kaiser roll and caraway seeds. It serves 6 and is rated easy to cook.

Start cooking
Beef on weck (Buffalo roast beef sandwich)
Photo: Nickgray, via TasteAtlas · licensed
Prep
20 min
Cook
1 h 15 min
Rest
20 min
Total
1 h 55 min
Serves
6
Level
Easy
Calories
480

Main ingredients

Ingredients

6 sandwiches

For the roast beef

For the jus

For the kummelweck rolls

To serve

Method

Roast beef

1 h 5 min
  1. Step 1

    Heat the oven (opens in a new tab) to 220 °C. Rub the beef with oil, garlic (opens in a new tab), salt and pepper (opens in a new tab) and roast for 15 minutes, then lower to 160 °C and roast until the centre reaches 52–54 °C for rare-medium rare, about 45–55 minutes more.

    Food safety: Wash hands, boards and knives after handling raw meat, and keep it apart from salad and other ready-to-eat food.

    A tray of food roasting in the oven
    How it looks · Photo: locrifa on Pexels

Jus

6 min
  1. Step 2

    Rest the beef on a board, loosely covered, for 20 minutes. Pour the stock into the roasting pan (opens in a new tab), scrape up the browned bits and simmer for 5 minutes to make a jus; keep it hot.

Kummelweck rolls

14 min
  1. Step 3

    Make the kummelweck: brush the tops of the rolls with egg white (opens in a new tab), sprinkle thickly with caraway seeds (opens in a new tab) and coarse salt and bake at 200 °C for 4–5 minutes until the topping sets.

  2. Step 4

    Slice the beef as thinly as you possibly can across the grain and dip the slices briefly in the hot jus.

To serve

4 min
  1. Step 5

    Split the rolls, pile in the beef, spread horseradish (opens in a new tab) on the top half and quickly dip the cut side of the top in jus before closing. Serve with extra horseradish and a pickle.

    • 4 min
    A finished dish being plated
    How it looks · Photo: Willians Huerta on Pexels

At a glance

Beef on weck (Buffalo roast beef sandwich) in 4 stages: roast beef in a pan, then jus in a pan, then kummelweck rolls in a bowl, then to serve in a bowl.
  1. 1 · Roast beef in a pan

    • Beef sirloin steak
    • Salt
    • Black pepper
    • Garlic
    • Neutral vegetable oil
  2. then rest

    2 · Jus in a pan

    • Beef stock
  3. then make

    3 · Kummelweck rolls in a bowl

    • Kaiser roll
    • Egg white
    • Caraway seeds
    • Salt
  4. then split

    4 · To serve in a bowl

    • Prepared horseradish
    • Dill pickles

About this dish

Origin
Buffalo, New York, United States · Commonly attributedThe kummelweck roll came with German immigrants; the sandwich became a tavern staple in 19th-century Buffalo, possibly because the salty roll sold more beer.More food from United States
Map of the region around United States, with United States highlighted
United States
Dish
Lunch · Dinner · Sandwiches · Main courses
Cooking method
Roasted, Oven-baked
Taste
savoury, salty, spicy (chilli heat), aromatic / warmly spiced
Diet
Dairy-free · No nut ingredients · High-protein
All labelsNon-vegetarian · Dairy-free · No nut ingredients · No added sugar · Alcohol-free · Pork-free · High-protein · Calorie-conscious
Worked out from the ingredients. How labels work
Good for
Make-ahead

Allergens

  • May contain: Milkfrom kaiser roll, prepared horseradish
  • Contains: Eggsfrom kaiser roll, egg white, prepared horseradish
  • Contains: Wheatfrom kaiser roll
  • Contains: Glutenfrom kaiser roll
  • May contain: Sesamefrom kaiser roll
  • May contain: Mustardfrom prepared horseradish, dill pickles
  • May contain: Celeryfrom beef stock
  • May contain: Sulphitesfrom prepared horseradish

Based on typical versions of these ingredients and not verified allergen-free. Brands differ and cross-contact happens, so always check labels. For severe allergies, follow your clinician’s advice.

Nutrition

480 kcal per serving

Estimated

1 serving ≈ 374 g · recipe makes 6

Where the energy comes from

  • Protein 45%
  • Carbohydrate 30%
  • Fat 26%
Nutrition per serving and per 100 g
NutrientPer servingPer 100 g*
Energy480 kcal128 kcal
Protein52.3 g14 g
Carbohydrate34.7 g9.3 g
Net carbohydrate31.3 g8.4 g
Sugars1.8 g0.5 g
Added sugars0 g0 g
Fibre3.3 g0.9 g
Fat13.5 g3.6 g
Saturated fat3.8 g1 g
Trans fat——
Cholesterol120 mg32 mg
Sodium2630 mg703 mg
Salt equivalent6.6 g1.8 g
Vitamins & minerals per serving
Potassium
1006 mg
Calcium
141 mg
Iron
5.6 mg
Magnesium
75 mg
Vitamin A (RAE)
1 µg
Vitamin C
4 mg
Vitamin D
0.2 µg
Vitamin B12
2.2 µg
Folate (DFE)
137 µg

How these numbers were made

  • Calculated from USDA FoodData Central (SR Legacy) per-100 g values and the listed quantities.
  • *Per 100 g of combined raw ingredients; the cooked dish may weigh more or less.
  • Optional ingredients are not included: dill pickles.
  • Kaiser roll: French rolls (FDC 172795) as a stand-in; kaiser rolls are crusty, lean white-flour hard rolls of very similar composition.
  • “—” means the value isn’t known for enough of the ingredients; it is never zero by default.
  • Values are estimates for guidance, not for medical dosing. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Research Service. FoodData Central, 2019. fdc.nal.usda.gov.

Good to know

Tips

  • A slicing machine or a very sharp knife on well-rested, slightly cooled beef gives the wafer-thin slices Buffalo taverns are known for.
  • Freshly grated horseradish is fiercer than jarred; add sparingly.

Common mistakes

  • Overcooking the beef: it should be pink, as it warms further in the jus.

Serve with

  • Serve with dill pickles, French fries and a cold lager.
  • Offer extra jus in small cups for dunking.

Food safety

  • Whole-muscle beef roasts are commonly served rare; cook to 63 °C for anyone who is pregnant, very young, elderly or immunocompromised.
  • Wash hands, boards and knives after handling raw meat, and keep it apart from salad and other ready-to-eat food.

Storage

  • Leftover roast beef keeps 3 days refrigerated; store rolls separately at room temperature.

Variations

  • Beef on weck with au jus on the side: The roll is left dry and the jus served in a cup for dipping, French-dip style.

Original editorial recipe · FriendsPantry editorial · source: TasteAtlas (dish facts) · Not yet independently reviewed · Added

Recipe DNA

How this dish is built

Built from the recipe’s own sections. Each band’s width is its share of the dish by weight. Choose a component to see what it does.

What the dish is built around

For the roast beef

Used in step 1

Reviews & corrections

Reviews come from signed-in cooks and appear after a moderator checks them. We never show made-up ratings.